★★☆☆☆
Stayed at the hotel and had dinner in the restaurant/bar. The room was way too small and had no room on the sides of the bed to get in and out. Bathroom was very small and door did not close completely. Linens were minimal and appeared worn and stained. View from windows was smokestacks from the kitchen. The bar and restaurant were lively and staff were excellent. Food was mostly good, although vegetables that came with the entrees were unappealing- a large serving of mixed squash, carrots and beans. Love the historic building but was not worth the price we paid. The neighborhood had a a few charming shops but many boarded up buildings and seems to be in the process of revitalization.
★★★★★
Great bar and hotel from at least 100 but more like 150 years ago. I hadn’t been there for some years and till yesterday but when I returned it was the exact same inviting old school Irish bar vibe. A lot of happy people eating robust meals. I stayed with beer and snacks but the blooming onion and sweet potato fries were a meal on their own. Can’t wait to go back!
★★★★★
Went here with my bf for his birthday. We at the restaurant but didn't stay at the hotel. Our server Colby was very attentive and kind! All the food was consistent and the drinks were great. Great spot in Port Jervis!
Update: Stayed at the Erie Hotel for one night during Labor Day weekend and the room was very comfortable and clean. They don't serve breakfast but there's plenty of spots within walking distance that serve breakfast. Would definitely come back.
★★★★★
This review is only for the restaurant since there was no sojourn in the hotel. The restaurant serves delicious food, especially the Erie wrap. There are numerous beers on tap, including Allagash Tipel and Blue Moon. The bathroom is clean and the waitstaff friendly. In September 2026, the Orange County Libertarian Party held its biennial convention at this location.
★★★☆☆
The restaurant, service quick, no one was in there. Every person that we saw working there had a sour puss on, not one smile between them. There was no one in there but my friend & myself since they just opened up.
I had a burger, ordered medium, this way maybe it may not be well done, it was totally well done, dry as the stale bread it was on. The tomatoes were inedible, whoever is the cook..really???
The fries were excellent.
I had wanted to go there for years, if I had to base it on this time it would be my last time. But I may give it one more try, def not a burger!
Service w a smile, not in this place!